New York City’s horse-drawn carriage industry is fighting back against Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s decision to eliminate the historic Central Park carriage rides.
The Transport Workers Union (TWU), carriage drivers and industry representatives filed a federal lawsuit against the city on Thursday, November 19th, challenging the legislation banning the industry.
The lawsuit argues that the new law threatens the livelihoods, property rights and financial investments of carriage owners and drivers.
TWU Local 100, two carriage drivers and a carriage medallion owner are among the plaintiffs.
The union argues that the city is effectively taking away privately owned businesses, city-issued carriage medallions and other property without guaranteeing fair compensation.
The lawsuit also challenges the city’s failure to conduct an independent valuation of carriage medallions or adequately assess the financial impact of eliminating the industry. Some medallions were purchased for hundreds of thousands of dollars, representing substantial investments for their owners.
Additionally, the lawsuit challenges the city’s prohibition against selling horses to other carriage operators in jurisdictions where the industry remains legal.
TWU International President John Samuelsen called the legislation an “unconstitutional abomination,” arguing that the city should have included enforceable financial protections for affected workers.
Mamdani signed Romanch’s Law, named after 18-year-old tourist Romanch Mahajan, who died following a carriage accident in Central Park in June 2026. The legislation requires all horse-drawn carriage operations to cease by June 1, 2028.
The administration says approximately 200 workers will receive assistance through a proposed medallion buyback program, job training, career counseling and educational opportunities. A detailed worker transition plan is expected by April 2027.
For the drivers, stable workers, horse handlers and small-business owners whose livelihoods depend on the carriage industry, the fight is about more than preserving a tourist attraction. It is about protecting working people from losing their jobs, businesses and financial investments without a clear plan for fair compensation or long-term economic security.
The lawsuit raises broader questions about how city government treats workers and small-business owners when major policy decisions threaten their livelihoods.
As the case moves forward, hundreds of affected workers and their families face uncertainty about their economic future and whether the city will be held accountable for the financial consequences of eliminating an industry that has operated in New York City for generations.





